00:00
00:00
tallestrose

9 Movie Reviews

2 w/ Responses

1 reviews is hidden due to your filters.

Yikes. While I could understand your message that "both extremes are snowflakes", I would argue that a lack of political stance was fun and original a couple years ago. But now that human rights are at risk during this horrible presidency, this jaded and nihilist viewpoint is unproductive and only serves to damage the discourse further.

YULFO83 responds:

Hi tallestrose, thank you for your feedback. although my message does come across more from a nihilistic point of view the message was more about how things are handled. theres an ignorance on both sides that seem to completely take over and we lose the real argument because we react on emotion. the argument appears more like 2 bitter devoice parents trying to convince you that one is worse than the other. Its not about communication its about how we are gonna get the other group in trouble so we look better. ALSO, I do make fun of myself right in the beginning, the narrator leaves once he finds out politics is the subject of the cartoon. he has no opinion. he just wants whisky. having no opinion and avoiding the subject can be a lot more damaging than the 2 extremes.

Watching this animation, it's clear that the author had a lot to say about:
- Third wave feminism
- Transgender and non-binary people
- Genital mutilation

This author tries so desperately to state his opinions on various social issues that he ends up mixing them all together into one nonexistent problem. On top of that, the one-dimensional parody of radical feminism is just a reason to point at it and laugh, in a way that screams: "SJWs, am I right?".

The ending song gives you the impression that this should be taken seriously, like it's the author's saving grace that will give meaning to his confused message. Its lyrics about avoiding genital mutilation could have potential if they talked about how babies are, even to this day, subject to circumcision or other life-changing operations, all without their consent. Instead, the author insists on denigrating consenting adults who partake in sexual reassignment surgery, despite many studies supporting that physical changes are successful in helping transgender people.

It all just feels like some more transphobic propaganda we don't need in a society where transgender people are still victims of hate crime.

In the end, it is clear that a lot of effort was put into this short animation. It is unfortunate that the author didn't put the same effort in learning more about its subject matter.

The art is sloppy (besides the lovely picture of them walking away at the end), but it just goes to show that you don't need gorgeous art to make something good. Besides, it resembling an animatic fits perfectly with this context of a brainstorming writer.

I like the different versions the narrative gets rewritten into, and the deadpan delivery is spot on, especially at the end. It was a delight and it made me chuckle. <3

I love this so much! The animation is astounding; the transitions from each individual the protagonist becomes is absolutely magical and your choice of music fits perfectly.

Amazing work!

I mean... this short animation exaggeratedly yet somewhat accurately represents the humor and style that some featured Newgrounds animators rely on.

Sloppiness, even when it's intentional, isn't clever nor enjoyable.

This is deeply moving. The animation blew me away and the story was highly captivating. Everything about it is perfect.

For all the random, disturbing or nonsensical Flash cartoons that are popular out there, this gem is a beautiful change of pace, and its charming message is indeed worth being told. Amazing! <3

For a first cartoon, this isn't bad! The designs are highly simplistic, however I personally enjoy the witty dialogue and the shenanigans that ensue. Great work!

Rdg92 responds:

Thanks for the feedback!

...(speechless)...

I rarely give a 10 outta 10, but this Flash is so well thought and awesome, I need to give it.

I don't even find any proper words to describe it. :P

I just think it's really, really well thought. Great job!
___
DxH

One word : LOLWUT

I simply love this :P Really nice and original.
Also, I wanted to review this... pour te saluer parce que j'suis québécois moi aussi. Hah. :P

8/10, bon Flash!
___
DxH

Queer French artist. Sweet and salty. She/her.

Female

Canada

Joined on 6/18/11

Level:
8
Exp Points:
592 / 710
Exp Rank:
> 100,000
Vote Power:
5.01 votes
Audio Scouts
1
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
86,249
Blams:
10
Saves:
57
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
54
Supporter:
5y 1d